The tenth installment of music reviews from the GREENBELT festival held at Cheltenham Racecourse, 26th to 29th August.
Continued from page 4
DUKE SPECIAL - Mainstage - 8:15pm
Belfast's
idiosyncratic 'vaudeville' artist delivered his music hall style to
the Greenbelt throng with some twinkling piano riffs and a display of
quirky and consistently clever songwriting. Accompanied by eccentric
drummer 'Temperance Society' Chip Bailey, renowned for his use of
cheese graters and whisks as percussion instruments, amongst other
diverse instrumentalists, the Duke's toe-tapping compositions,
artfully evocative lyrics and interaction with the crowd engaged
everybody, getting the audience to all join in with the black humour
chorus of "Digging An Early Grave". Song themes ranged from pitiful
longing and desperation to spirituality, with the latter featuring
heavily in many, like the bouncy "Salvation Tambourine", about
searching for God. Mr Special was joined onstage by previous Mainstage
performer Gordon Gano for the slower "Why Does Anybody Love?" to
rapturous applause. However, the inclusion of a saxophone within the
performance didn't work. The set closed on a cover of Joy Division's
"Love Will Tear Us Apart", during which the Duke challenged the
denominational nature of Christianity and how squabbling over small
theological details has torn the body of Christ into fragments. "God
is bigger than that," Duke boldly stated.
Andrew Townend
IDLEWILD - Mainstage - 9:30pm
With no
new album to promote and with their best days long behind them,
Scotland's alt rockers Idlewild seemed a bizarre choice for Sunday's
Mainstage headline slot - the band themselves even seemed a little
baffled as to what they were doing there. "We're out of retirement for
one night only," offered frontman Roddy Woomble by way of introduction
before the band sleepwalked their way through a pedestrian set of
bland indie stodge. Spikier material from the group's 1998 debut
'Captain' at least broke up the monotony and hits "American English"
and "You Held The World In Your Arms" did sound good played on the
large outdoor stage. Unfortunately though, Roddy's attempts to connect
with the audience fell a little flat; "Is that a horse or a donkey?"
he half-heartedly enquired about a soft toy held aloft in the crowd
and he later complained when a guitar tuning issue once again meant he
had to address the GB throng. It's hard to complain about Greenbelt's
choice of headliners when the majestic Mavis Staples, the charming
Billy Bragg and the sublime Get Cape. Wear Cape. Fly featured, but
here's hoping next year's selection doesn't include any Britpop
has-beens.
Peter Timmis
HOPE AND SOCIAL - Performance Café - 10:00pm
Stood onstage at the start of their set were five men in blue blazer
attire looking very smart and very coordinated. The band have been
described by The Independent as "one of the UK's top five live bands"
and from the moment their crisp rhythms and masterly harmonies kicked
in it was clear they intended to live up to such accolades. An array
of clever mixed songs, their own "The Road Is Long" with Paul
McCartney's "Blackbird" thrown in was unexpected but absolutely
worked! Their banter revealed that three members have been in the band
for 12 years but they then recruited more musicians and changed the
name four years ago. Another song "The Family Man" penned by Hope And
Social's Simon Wainwright, had written this about his own personal
journey. Their set featured three very strong lead singers who manage
to share out the songs with no hint of rivalry while their quirky and
fascinating keys player Ed Waring wore a hat with lights! The set
finished with a humble announcement that CDs were being sold in the
G-Music Tent but offered at a price of whatever the audience felt fit
to pay. A great offer from a great band.
Jojo Meadows
JAX WALKER - Underground - 10.00pm
Jax Walker
and band pull out all the stops for their Underground set, bringing a
tight, pop-funk vibe that doesn't let up until the very end. Up
against Idlewild on mainstage, the turn-out was disappointing, but
what the crowd lacked in quantity they made up in jumping and dancing
for the entire set. Jax is an amiable host, grateful to the crowd,
proud of his band with a cracking image.The combination of hip hop and
indie works well with plenty of 80s references both musically and
lyrically peppered along the way, the most satisfying being a
adaptation of the lyrics from Ray Parker's 'Ghostbusters'.
Satisfyingly, here was one of the tightest bands that I've seen over
the weekend. The sound was fantastic:swathes of retro 80s synths,
keyboard brass stabs, the odd 808 tom and a drummer with a constant
bass foot and solid beats. The guitars were spiky and singer Sol has
energy and a great voice. The bassist not only has, for my money THE
best mustache of GB11, but also a great funk sensibility, pounding out
solid grooves that brought to mind Stevie Wonder and Michael Jackson,
particularly on the track 'Money'.The Jackson link was confirmed for
'Pack Of Lies', the baseline is surely a homage to 'Billie Jean' and
Jax encouraged the crowd were encouraged to do their best MJ
impression. A foray into 'scuzzy electro' didn't do much for me and
while there was plenty of imagination and flair in the set, there was
not much scope for a change of pace. Still, new track 'Tentacles' is a
sign of good things to come for Walker's next release and he clearly
intends to bring the party spirit and keep it, and that he did,
commendably so. For what it's worth, the elderly gentleman next to me
declares their set to be 'much better than Duke Special'. If you
weren't there, you missed out.
Ewan Jones
MONDAY, 29th August
MYTH OF BEN - Underground - 11.00am
A rather
small crowd stood motionless to watch a fairly catchy and pretty tight
alt rock band from Clapham kick things off for Monday's Meltdown
Sessions. It's hard to criticise the band in any individual aspect
except that their own brand of melodic post hardcore just didn't
massively grab me, nor did it seem to have much of an effect on the
crowd assembled. The band members member seems to be from somewhere
else, each claim to bring their own unique influences, maybe this
explains why they don't yet have a coherent overall sound. Fans of
Further Seems Forever and Thrice will appreciate that the band clearly
has taken an influence from them but will then go back to listening to
Further Seems Forever and Thrice. Having said all that this was a
solid start for a fairly new band; all they need to do now is write a
few more memorable songs.
Greg Sammons
RISEN FROM RUINS - Underground - 11.40am
These
guys have clearly come a good distance since I first saw them, putting
on a tight and engaging performance which included a couple of
genuinely good songs. They still, to my mind, haven't quite worked out
what their sound is though. It's got an ethereal quality, plenty of
classic rock/metal vibes, slightly celtic/folky tones in places and a
progressive edge as well. Put them all together and it just doesn't
quite (yet) gel. Lead vocalist Ian Jervis and son Ed both put in some
excellent axework in places, only bettered at Greenbelt by the mighty
Paul May in my opinion. The rhythm section was tight, Danielle Jervis
recently joined on bass making it four out five of the members being
from the same family, whilst the drummer really showed his wares on
their standout track Alive. Poor old Lisa was rather left out on keys
and backing vocals, maybe the soundman didn't spot her as the keyboard
only become audible in their penultimate song and her vocals on their
last. It's a shame as her slightly gothic and ethereal sound adds a
really nice layer to their music and allows the band's more
progressive side to develop. The musicianship is pretty high and there
are some great moments within their set but who their target audience
is and what their sound will end up as is anybody's guess.
Greg Sammons
SAEED HASHEM - Performance Café - 11:45am
Poet
and songwriter Saeed Awaz Hashemi was born in the Bamyan region of
Afghanistan but was persecuted and imprisoned for his faith by the
ruling Taliban before managing to escape and flee to England where he
now lives with some of his family. Saeed took to the Performance Café
stage and sang in a Persian dialect called Hazaragi while playing
dutar (a long-necked lute with two strings). To western ears the sound
produced may not have been too harmonious but those sitting in the
packed venue were clearly fascinated. After a couple of lengthy
numbers the 70 year old musician was clearly exhausted so his son came
onstage to be interviewed by a compere. The young man explained his
father's life story and also told of his own imprisonment by the
Taliban which ended with a daring escape where he crawled through a
toilet and swam across a river to secure his freedom. Saeed took to
the stage to perform one more of his compositions and was clearly
moved at the positive reaction he received from the crowd.
Peter Timmis
THE ORIGIN - Underground - 12.20pm
With their
female lead singer and their accessible emo vibe it'd be all too easy
to compare them to Paramore and now I've gone and done it. In all
honestly it is a useful starting point in terms of comparison, made
all the more obvious when their lead singer has dyed (at least I think
it's dyed) her hair ginger ala Hayley Williams. I've known about these
guys for a good while and through their drummer Al King have been kept
regularly up to date with their developments. Here is a band with
drive, passion and goals; not only that but they are relevant to a
large section of today's young people. A series of well structured
and tightly performed tracks quickly took us to a new track they'd
written just a few days prior, they said it didn't have a name but it
clearly should be called "I Can't Breathe". Whilst they may not be
blazing a new musical trail they have produced a solid set of tunes
and ended with the best of the lot, "Ghosts".
Greg
Sammons
LIAM BLAKE - Performance Café - 1:00pm
This was
one of the sets I'd most wanted to see at Greenbelt. Those who've so
far heard it are of one voice in proclaiming Liam's 'You And Other
Stories' one of the best albums of the year and all that was left for
this reviewer to decide was whether Liam could deliver before a three
quarters full Performance Café tent already thinking of prosaic
matters like packing up tents and the journey home. In fact Liam
triumphed, with the razor-sharpness of a singer/songwriter whose music
is just what Phil Jupitus called it "achingly lovely". Maybe it's
Liam's rich, smooth voice with its arresting swoops into falsetto
which draws us in. Or maybe Liam's ability to weave evocative pictures
with his lyrics yet never resorting to strained metaphor or tired
cliché. Or perhaps Liam's lilting folk pop - at the Café ably
filled out by electric guitar, bass and percussion - which makes this
songsmith so special. But special he is and everything about Laim's
set conveyed a gentle warmth that immediately engaged the audience,
and after some of the angry polemic projected by other Greenbelt acts,
demonstrated that sometimes gentle reflection generates more than
angry rants. Some of the songs, like the evocative "For Your Sake" are
from his album. Others like the eerily enigmatic "Strange Town" are
newly minted. "Gypsy Fireflies" deftly depicts a girl's ability to
captivate ("He's chasing all the dreams she's weaving") while "Heart
& Soul", Liam's next single, was lifted by one of several fine
electric guitar solos from his accompanists. Liam's set prompted the
man next to me to bay loudly for an encore (little chance on the
tightly-scheduled Performance Café). I asked the fan where he'd heard
of Liam and was told Radio 2. He raved over Liam's live performance,
calling it "very Fleetwood Mac". Don't know about the description but
his enthusiasm bodes well for Liam's future.
Tony
Cummings
RISING FROM DEATH - Underground - 1.00pm
It's
been a tough ride for Swindon's Rising From Death, various setbacks
and personal (and personnel) problems have slowed down their
progression at times. Now, though, they seem to be rejuvenated and at
their best. The evolution from metalcore to tough guy hardcore seems
to be complete and the band seemed to have grown up a lot this set is
markedly different from their previous performance at Cheltenham
Racecourse in 2008. A good use of samples went down a treat, including
a warning of the Hellish consequences that so many face and C3PO's
invitation to a beatdown. The brothers Derry set the benchmark for
showmanship this year, working hard to get the crowd moving and
singing, this including getting us to sing "Ti Amo" during a Spanish
language song which I think translated as "To The One I Love". The
lads weren't afraid to use the stage as a platform to preach not just
about Jesus, and pretty blatantly I might add, but also in favour of
Straight Edge. The sXe spiel concluded with a massive round of
applause to John's case for Jesus being the only sure way to overcome
addictions, crutches and insecurities. Naturally this led to "Straight
Edge Is For Life, Not Just For XXXMas", recently recorded with Alex
Grieg of Malokai at his studio. Rising From Death's rousing set ended
on "A Call To Glory" which was marred by Chris Derry's voice being
almost completely shot, making his melodic vocals extremely strained.
Also his failed stage dive at the end added an unintentionally comedy
moment.
Greg Sammons
FISCHY MUSIC - Mainstage - 1:00pm
A Scottish
charity aimed at working with Primary Schools and Churches, Fischy
Music under the expert stewardship of Steve Fischbacker brought their
popular brand of positive children's songs to Mainstage for a sunny
afternoon and I brought my 18 month old boy to gauge his reaction.
He's a little under the target age but he happily danced around as a
children's choir, sign language interpreter, dancers and band took to
the stage to provide an entertaining show. The songs are as popular
with adults as they are with children and the singers were great at
getting everyone in the field involved. For my part I enjoyed
second-guessing which pop and rock bands the musicians were giving a
cheeky nod too (Queen? check. T-Rex? check. Santana? check.) At times
the set felt too much like a sales pitch to the adults with the aim of
getting the resources into schools and churches. What I found more
frustrating was that the songs had little to no Gospel content. I'm
more than aware of the nature of what you can and can't say and
promote in schools and of the need to be sensitive and sensible in how
messages are communicated. But songs like "Someone Is With You" just
don't really make any sense if you don't know who the "someone" is. If
you're not going to specify who you're singing about it's a song that
feels frustratingly empty. Messages like "the bad times don't last
forever", "we will find a way", "you are a star just the way you are"
and "you'll be stronger every time you get back up" are all well and
good but suggest that we are the strong and positive solutions to all
our problems and fail to point to a greater need - or a greater
hope.
Ewan Jones
BACK POCKET PROPHET - Underground - 1.40pm
In
the UK Christian hard music scene this has been one of the most
anticipated moments of the year, the launch of Back Pocket Prophet's
debut album 1:4. The taster track on their myspace did them no favours
at all but thankfully the live show more than made up for it. Vocalist
Dan Random is now fully bedded into the band and was showing his
excellent range to full effect. His stagework extended to a couple of
circuits around the crowd, they seemed to absolutely lap it up. What's
held back the band over the last couple of years has been a
fluctuating line-up, the album was due to be released months ago, but
their solution at Greenbelt was inspired. After wowing Greenbelt last
year in A.N.D, Paul May was back with his bespoke headless white
guitar. Once again Paul was noodling his way through specially
formulated song breaks, allowing him to demonstrate to us lot just how
good he is at making six strings sing. This set had been clearly well
rehearsed as each song slickly went into the next, fitting now
classics alongside some of their newer stuff. Bizarrely their weakest
moment was during a switch of vocals during their best known song, How
Can I Deny You. 2007 saw them debut their 80s thrash sound at
Greenbelt, in 2008 they returned and introduced the zombie conga to
Greenbelt, 2011 sees Back Pocket Prophet come of age.
Gregg
Sammons
PETER AND THE WULF - Performance Café - 1:45pm
Rather strangely, Peter And The Wulf are nothing to do with
Prokofiev but are a guy called Peter (guitars, mandolin) and a bloke
calling himself Wulf (double bass) plus a fiddle player called Jill.
I was sadly disappointed. The stage presence was dull and dreary,
there seemed to be a depressing weight that hovered over the room like
a cloud. I had enough rain at Greenbelt not to sit in a tent feeling
it was raining outside and out! I tried to persevere tuning my ear to
their English folk set but it truly was all pretty dreary.
Jojo Meadows
GENTRY MORRIS - Performance Café - 2:30pm
It
was a rather breathless Gentry Morris on stage at the Performance
Cafe, having only arrived on site at lunchtime following a lengthy
journey which started in Belfast at 3am and included a road closure
induced diversion which resulted in getting lost in the Cotswolds. But
if Gentry had to suffer for his art, we were the beneficiaries as the
following 40 minutes demonstrated precisely why his most recent album,
the independently released 'Awake O Sleeper', was given a 10 square
review by Cross Rhythms. Originally from Georgia and recording in
Nashville, Gentry Morris now lives in Northern Ireland and his
songwriting reflects that mixture of influences. Accompanied by
Stephen Macartney on resonator guitar and backing vocals, most of the
songs were from Gentry's current album including the exquisitely
beautiful title track. This is music that was made for the intimate
setting of the Performance Cafe, and the appreciative audience were
lapping it up.
Mark Goodge
GREENBELT JAZZ ORCHESTRA - Centaur - 2:30pm
One
of Greenbelt's more adventurous and exciting ideas for this year's
festival was a couple of scratch band performances. Talented
festivalites were invited to become part of this band under the
direction of American band leader Scott Stroman. Scott has an
impressive CV, having worked with Dizzy Gillespie, Billy Cobham, Phil
Collins and many others. He currently directs the London Jazz
Orchestra, the Guildhall Jazz Band And Jazz Singers and the Eclectic
Voices Choir. This band of around 15 Greenbelters had two rehearsals
and then were thrust straight into the gig. As you might expect the
players were of varying standards, but Scott clearly possessed the
gift of getting the best out of people, using the ensemble to build a
perfect foundation for soloists and giving them plenty of chances to
show off their jazz chops. The set focused on the works of Duke
Ellington, opening with "Ko-Ko", a fast tempo piece with plenty of
soloing opportunities. This was followed by Stan Kenton's "Here's That
Rainy Day", a subtle piano intro built through a strong crescendo into
a powerful, slow band piece. As the set progressed Scott took the
opportunity to teach the crowd a little about how the touring bands
used to build their repertoire and evolve their arrangements on the
road. This was illustrated to us in Count Basie's "One O'Clock Jump"
as the band had three set riffs for the song and Scott brought them
each in underneath the melody and solos as the mood took him. This
fantastic set was brought to a close by three more Duke Ellington
classics, "Caravan", "Prelude To A Kiss" and finally "Rockin' In
Rhythm". The musicians certainly enjoyed themselves. So did the
audience.
Andy Long
HOPE AND SOCIAL - Mainstage - 2:45pm
For their third and final show of Greenbelt '11 Hope And Social took
to the Mainstage in their trademark blue blazers in front of a large
crowd there to enjoy the afternoon sunshine but also keen to check out
the critically acclaimed group. The guys weren't feeling at their best
though after what they described as "an incident with a Kentucky Fried
Chicken". Having said that, the Leeds-based band put on a great show
with group members sharing vocal duties and clearly enjoying the
Mainstage experience. "Pitching Far Too High" included some hilarious
improvised lyrics about KFC and the rocking "Family Man" was enhanced
by some great contributions from the three-piece brass section. The
best song of the set though was the banjo-led "A Darkness Now Is
Coming" which, despite the title, was a goodtime country rocker which
suited the mood of the day perfectly.
Peter Timmis
AHAB - Mainstage - 3:45pm
North London four
piece Ahab followed breakout festival stars Hope And Social onto
Mainstage and continued to keep people on their feet with their upbeat
brand of country folk. Close harmonies were beautifully realised and
were as much Crosby, Stills & Nash as Mumford And Sons. Ahab
actually did well in maintaining a consistent style that was really
more informed by American country than footstomping Brit folk. Never
were Ahab's Americana leanings clearer than in the closing Old Crow
Medicine Show cover "Wagon Wheel" ("Rock me mama like a wagon wheel").
You really would have sworn you were listening to a band straight out
of Nashville. The full band compliment of drums, bass, two acoustic
guitars and mandolin made for an energetic set that benefited from the
much improved Mainstage PA. Obligatory instrument swaps and a "no
off-mic discussion" policy led for some entertaining, and possibly
rehearsed, conversation and while there were no standout tracks Ahab
proved to be easy listening for a bank holiday afternoon.
Ewan Jones
CHASING OWLS - Underground - 3:50pm
A quiet buzz
had been whispering its way around the festival in anticipation of
this band's appearance, so it was no surprise to see that they had
drawn a good sized crowd to Greenbelt's newly located Underground
venue. The Edinburgh-based four-piece play an energetic yet intimate
brand of folky pop tunes and the crowd were quick to pick up on this
energy and get involved. Their sound brought back the glory days of
Greenbelt favourites Eden Burning along with their mandolin twanging
friends Why? and my personal favourites The Pink Dandelions. Chasing
Owls bring together beautiful harmonies, artful musicianship and that
elusive ability to write memorable songs. I am going to have to check
out their debut release, 'We Began', very soon. If you haven't yet
heard Chasing Owls you can find some great examples of their skills on
Youtube.
Andy Long
MAJOR MAJOR - Underground - 5:10pm
Over the past
few years this young Liverpool-based band have gained a reputation as
a fantastic live act and in 2008 they played in front of 5000 people
at their hometown's Capital Of Culture opening event, so it's
surprising that so few people made their way to the Underground venue
to see them. Major Major didn't seem fazed by the low turnout though
and as they took to the stage confident frontman Conor Clarke
commented, "You lucky five people!" The band played an energetic set
full of great pop hooks, choppy guitar riffs and big choruses with
hints of Franz Ferdinand and Dr Feelgood. Guitarist Neil Owen even
played with such vigour that his fingers began to bleed over his
instrument! Highlights of the set were the thumping "We're Coming
Alive", the danceable "Popular Boys" and "The Dirtiest Word" ("This
one features no swearing, despite the name," explained Clarke). A
short set but one that showed great potential.
Peter
Timmis
KATE RUSBY - Mainstage - 5:50pm
Back at
Greenbelt eight years after her first appearance in 2003, Kate Rusby
attracted a sizeable early evening crowd at Mainstage. A set comprised
mostly of songs from her recent album, 'Make The Light' was
interspersed with what, like every cliche peddling reviewer, I can now
describe as her trademark Yorkshire wit and warmth and provided an
uplifting contrast to the distinctly unseasonal chill in the air. It's
difficult to pick out any particular highlights since it was all
uniformly good, but the juxtaposition of an older track, "The Good
Man", telling of a cuckolded husband, with "The Wishing Wife" from the
current album, a song about a wife having to put up with (and
ultimately deal with) a selfish husband was something which certainly
brought a smile to my face. Much of Kate Rusby's material is
self-penned (including all of "Make The Light"), and yet it fits in
very well with the traditional folk songs that are also a part of her
repertoire. In fact, probably the biggest change since her previous
Greenbelt appearance has been her emergence as a songwriter of note as
well as a performer. As with all traditional music forms, contemporary
folk is hard to pitch right as a composer; if the new material is too
different then it strays too far from the genre while if it sticks too
closely to the formula then it's little more than pastiche. Ms Rusby's
songwriting slips neatly into the sweet spot between those two
extremes. As a fellow member of the audience commented, "It were dead
good".
Mark Goodge
RON SEXSMITH - Mainstage - 7:00pm
A small but
dedicated group of fans waited at Mainstage with great anticipation
for Mojo magazine's favourite Canadian singer/songwriter. The evening
air began to chill and while Ron's set was a pleasant enough listen it
didn't do much to warm up those of us who had benefited from the more
upbeat vibe that the afternoon had so far offered. The band performed
mid-tempo, Radio 2-friendly Americana that was faultless in its
presentation but failed to draw a large crowd. Starting gently and
enjoying some friendly rapport with the fans, Sexsmith seemed to enjoy
playing host for half an hour, wryly joking about his resemblance to
Shrek as the set progressed he did shift up a gear. Highlights were
the bluesy "Jazz At The Bookstore" that put me in mind of 'Wild Wood'
era Paul Weller, "Impossible World", a beautifully constructed tune
that was added to the setlist after a request via the website and
"Love Shines", the title of the film made about Ron's attempts to find
commercial recognition. All pleasant enough but one couldn't help feel
Ron's set would have been better placed in the Centaur or Big Top.
Ewan Jones
SOUNDS OF SALVATION - Underground - 7:00pm
One
of the highlights of last year's Greenbelt festival was an incredibly
lively performance by Reading-based ska punk aggregation Sounds Of
Salvation and this year they were even better! The nine-piece group's
ska-based sound also takes in punk, worship and rap laced with brass
and backed by some seriously funky rhythms. Soon everyone in the
packed Underground venue was having a great time with many singing
along, clapping, skanking and even playing air-guitar to vibrant and
fun songs like "You Are". A highlight of the set was a number with
which Cross Rhythms Radio listeners will already be well familiar,
"The Facebook Song" with hilarious lyrics like "Even Tim Hughes is on
Facebook. . . and he is my best friend". Frontman Michael Whiteman was
extremely passionate and entertaining between songs describing the
band's fusion of rap metal with ska as "skrap metal" and Eddie
Edwards' trumpet solos were excellent throughout. SOS also took time
to perform a short worship set where they added a ska influence to
numbers like "Jesus Saves" and "Hosanna". A fun-filled show but one
with a strong message.
Peter Timmis
ANDREAS SANDLUND - Performance Café - 7:00pm
Andreas Sandlund is a keyboard player and songwriter hailing from
Stockholm who has released two albums. Aided by his deftly played keys
his songs were worshipful, gentle and in some ways inspirational. They
had simple, unspoilt melodies and at times something of an innate
beauty. This was Christian radio-friendly material to a 't' and I can
see the appeal for many listeners. For me personally I found the
low-key performance a little lacking in passion though he is clearly a
skilled songsmith. Judging from the enthusiastic reception he received
there were a few folk intent on buying his 'Sacred Love' album after
the set.
Andy Long
LUKE LEIGHFIELD - Underground - 8:00pm
The
weekend's Longest Queue To Get Into A Venue award goes to
Southampton-based Luke who, as well as being described as "the busiest
man in indie" was also the busiest man at last year's Greenbelt having
played no less than four shows at the festival. This year many of the
folk who saw one of those excellent performances were keen to
experience more of Leighfield's finely crafted piano-driven pop rock
and, despite suffering from a sore throat, he did not disappoint.
Seeming genuinely surprised by the strong turnout Luke wryly told the
packed Underground venue "I want to cram in the 'hits' for you" before
launching into the sublime pop perfection of "Have You Got Heart?" and
"Every Day". Fans were also treated to never before performed material
from Luke's upcoming new album including "It's You" with a huge chorus
that looks set to become a live favourite. Luke was joined by a first
rate band including a three-piece brass section and duel guitarists
that proved effective on a powerful rendition of "60,000 Miles".
"Greenbelt has been the highlight of my year" gushed Luke at the end
of his set and once again Luke was one of the highlights of
Greenbelt.
Peter Timmis
THE UNTHANKS - Mainstage - 8:15pm
If there's one
thing I like to close my festival with every year it's a spot of clog
dancing at Mainstage! Prior to the headlining set from the legendary
Mavis Staples, Monday night had more than a hint of folk about it,
what with sets from Kate Rusby and Ron Sexsmith. I had been looking
forward to The Unthanks all weekend and they were not about to
disappoint me. To my mind the band represent all the best elements of
British folk music, quintessential yet contemporary, brimming with the
integrity of ancient folk tales and overflowing with musical beauty
that has earned them critical acclaim and an eclectic mix of celebrity
fans. Their third album 'Last' followed sharply on the heels of its
predecessors, bringing together a set of beautiful undiscovered folk
tunes with some more contemporary covers. Rachel and Becky's gorgeous
voices have a hardy Northern edge and their band are the perfect
complement for them, their predominantly traditional sound also
carrying elements of jazz, blues and even progressive rock. I loved
the set, despite my unfamiliarity with much of the material, an
oversight I'm going to have to correct soon. For me it would have been
hard for The Unthanks to surpass the quality of their English folk
material, but towards the end they pulled a real surprise out of the
hat, with a cover of the King Crimson classic, "Starless". The prog
rockers are one of my all time favourites and here Crimson's song was
treated with reverence and tender appreciation by the folkies.
Absolutely beautiful. Oh yes, there genuinely was clog dancing -
honest.
Andy Long
REILLY - Performance Café - 9:00pm
I found it
refreshing to see Philadelphia's Reilly having great fun affirming the
Gospel message, both in the banter and in their songs (on a weekend
that characteristically endured some less helpful onstage chat from
bands and artists who should have known better). GB'11 marked the
band's first appearance in England and they seemed particularly taken
with the high quality of choice at the Greenbelt food stalls! Dove
nominated guitarist and singer John Reilly was an endearing frontman
and performed a genuine and moving rendition of 'It Is Well' that the
Performance Café crowd gently joined in with - his prophetic
introduction acknowledged that Jesus, the source and hope of
forgiveness is "not a very popular topic these days". The majority of
the set was kept moving by charismatic Dan Huie and the crowd enjoyed
the violin duets (and duels) that he shared with wife and violinist
Noele. An impromptu Irish jig kept us engaged while Reilly replaced
his second broken string of the day ("This never happens!"). Solid
backup came from drummer Jordan Lenhoff playing "the box" and bassist
Matthew Bomberger, who stayed in the background. The set continued at
a good pace ending with the (somewhat reluctant) audience getting to
their feet to join in for "Sunlight". Encouraging lyrics, a positive
attitude, a clear spiritual message and an engaging acoustic set
marked a pleasant end for me to Greenbelt 2011.
Ewan
Jones
MAVIS STAPLES - Mainstage - 9:30pm
If
you go to a lot of live gigs , once or twice you may be present at a
performance of such jaw-dropping magnificence that it will indelibly
imprint itself on your mind and you'll be able to recall songs,
details and the emotions you experienced decades after the event. Such
is the huge aesthetic and spiritual power of great music. And so it
becomes my duty, as a faithful chronicler of popular music to suggest
that for the second time in my life Mavis Staples convinced me that
not only is she the greatest living soul singer but also possesses
that rarest of gifts being able to fuse showbiz savvy with Holy Spirit
spontaneity to make art that is truly transcendent. The fact that this
could be achieved by someone who of the 13,000 or so punters, staff or
performers who attended this year's Greenbelt was probably the oldest
person there speaks much about our youth-obsessed culture. But the
fact is that this 71 year old great grandmother from Mississippi not
only delivered the definitive set at Christendom's longest running
festival, she performed music which for the second time in my life
took me to the heights. My first sublime Mavis Staples experience was
in Croydon in 1974 when a two thirds full Fairfield Hall witnessed
Mavis, Pops, Cleo and Yvonne pull out all the stops to show just why
Stax Records were getting massive R&B hits out of a downhome
family group. It was in the '70s of course that the Staple Singers
were at their height and their performance then of "I'll Take You
There (Come Go With Me)" and "Respect Yourself" showed that ol'
Roebuck had raised a group every bit as quintessential to R&B
history as AP Carter was to country music with the Carter Family. The
memory of Mavis that night in Croydon of wringing every heart-stopping
drop of emotion out of O V Wright's "You're Gonna Make Me Cry" has
stayed with me ever since. But that was 37 years ago. Pops and Pervis
have gone to glory (the latter absurdly noted as a sister in the GB
programme). And though Yvonne was still there onstage with her sister
together with another lady and a guy (who made a reasonable fist of
providing Pop's old vocal parts) who provided backups. In truth, I was
expecting little more at Greenbelt '11's Mainstage wrap-up performance
than one of those old-hits-for-the-fans run-throughs that veteran
performers usually dish out in the autumn of their years. Instead this
extraordinary lady took it to church with all the soul power singer's
half her age couldn't get close to. From the a cappella opener "Jesus
Is Mine", to the powerhouse rendition of "The Weight" (where her
superlative accompanists replicated all the gutsy power of The Band)
to a fiery rendition of "Freedom Highway" here was music where the
Gospel of Jesus Christ , the weight of the human condition, and the
heart cry for justice all met in music that exuded passion, anger,
pain and exaltant joy. Mavis' astonishing repertoire of growls, octave
leaps, moans, shrieks and gasps was as downhome as a chittlin supper
while her band with a drummer who looked like a bank manger but played
like James Brown's favourite son, and a guitarist able to squeeze
torrid blues licks in a style that could switch from Pops to BB King
seemingly at will, kept it righteous and right. Curtis Mayfield's "My
Country" sounded good, the even older "Too Close To Heaven" even
better. By the time Mavis had the Mainstage chanting "You take us
there" on the Staples "I'll Take You There" Stax classic it was clear
that we were witnessing a musical moment thousands will never forget.
Thank you Mavis, thank you Greenbelt.
Tony
Cummings
Andrew Townend is being WAY too soft on Duke Special about his Mainstage set and inparticular the Duke's closing remarks. DS helpfully told us to 'f*** denominations', without setting any personal context (NI?), or giving any further explanation or insight in to his well constructed argument - just throwing that out was a sour way to end the set and a 'shock' tactic to try and appear outspoken and 'other' in front of the very audience that has helped get him where he is.
Artistically, tacking his intellectually devoid contribution on to the end of 'Love Will Tear Us Apart' added further confusion as it made NO sense in the context of the song - is he saying Jesus' love causes people to tear apart, or our love for Jesus is earnest to the point where we tear him apart? Stupid, stupid, stupid, and I don't buy Townend's generous analysis either.
Greenbelt and its regular performers have a responsibility - what they say and do matters. Artistic expression does not trump integrity. Perhaps GB should give DS a year off.
By complete chance I was at the first greenbelt gig (I think) Duke Special ever did - 50 people in the old performance cafe - Duke with a piano and a gramophone, Chip with his percussion stick, and it was a revelation - as of GB11 the make-up's running, the charm has worn off and the novelty presentation ceases to be a draw. Shame, because there's some good songs kicking around in there.
Final thought - this is not a moral judgement (if you want to say f***, say f***), it's just an expression of frustration/disappointment - I'm almost reluctant to write it because I don't want Duke fans to pounce to his defence and make a martyr of a man who's quite capable of speaking for himself - certainly more articulately than he did in August.