The tenth installment of music reviews from the GREENBELT festival held at Cheltenham Racecourse, 26th to 29th August.
Continued from page 3
SUNDAY, 28th August
IDMC GOSPEL CHOIR - Mainstage - 11:45am
IDMC (Individuals Dedicated To The Ministry Of Christ) were formed
in 1994 by John Fisher, who has previously worked with LCGC and Chaka
Khan, and their sound is described as "contagious, urban and
contemporary". IDMC took to the stage straight after the Communion
Service to lead the Greenbelt throng in a 'gospel singalong set' that
opened with a joyous, Caribbean-tinged version of "Glory Be To God In
The Highest" that got the crowd dancing and singing from the first few
bars - the sun even came out over the Greenbelt site adding to the
goodtime atmosphere. Evergreens such as "You've Got A Friend" and
"Lord I Lift Your Name On High" were given the IDMC treatment with
deliciously funky beats and awesomely powerful vocals. There was also
a mass singalong of "Sing Low Sweet Chariot" and an unexpectedly
soulful version of the Beatles classic "All You Need Is Love". By the
time the choir closed their set with "This Little Light Of Mine"
everyone had a wide smile on their face.
Peter Timmis
HARRY BIRD AND THE RUBBER WELLIES - Performance Café - 12
noon
Now here was a Sunday lunchtime treat. Harry Bird,
Christophe Capewell and Paddy Durkan (minus accordion) kicked their
set off with some new songs and over the course of their 40 minutes
introduced some of the back catalogue, transforming a slightly subdued
but appreciative crowd into 'true fans' desperate to offer a
heartfelt, standing ovation to the troupe! Harry and co displayed a
wonderful ability to make a strong connection with their audience -
when not singing Harry always seemed to be interacting with the crowd,
smiling or laughing and at one point he even jumped up and down on the
spot with glee at an audience comment that tickled him. Paddy had a
fine range of percussion that he showcased in a sweet little solo
during "The Butterfly Song", while Christophe showed his dexterity on
a number of instruments including, keys, fiddle, ukelele and what
appeared to be a child's toy organ during a pirate song. The
highlights are too many to mention but I'll give you a few: Harry's
brother Jamie joining the band for the second half of the set; the
wonderful harmonies juxtaposed with the sharp, convicting lyrics of
"Who's Gonna Lead The March Upon The Jailhouse?"; the comedy build up
and execution of "The Beard Snood"; the roll-call to find out whether
Greenbelters who assured Jamie they would come had actually showed up
(they had), and rousing set closer "Ban The Bomb!". Why did HB&TRW
prove to be one of the most exciting acts of the weekend? Well, they
showcased a blend of acute, powerful, funny songwriting and
storytelling, a real sense of being friends together, the illusion of
simplicity that masked some incredibly powerful and moving songs (a
twist on the lyrics of trad folk song "He Was A Friend Of Mine" sung
as a tribute to friends suffering in Syria) and the vital ingredient -
warm humour. The band shifted effortlessly between the introspective
prayerfulness of "Dirty Hands" to a lighthearted song about cycling,
without ever seeming to just be anything other than themselves.
Thoroughly deserving of the warm reception they were accorded, this is
the kind of unique, fun, thought provoking band that Greenbelt should
be championing - let's see them on main stage next year.
Ewan
Jones
THE RISING with MARTYN JOSEPH, DUKE SPECIAL, GORDON GANO,
CATHY BURTON and LUKE JACKSON - Centaur - 12.30pm
The
Rising has become a Greenbelt institution over the years. For those
unfamiliar with it, it's part concert, part seminar in which Martyn
Joseph, the host, and his guests play a song each and then chat about
the art of songwriting before playing another song. It's hard to
assess an artist I've never heard before on the basis of just two
songs, but Luke Jackson's material demonstrated an amazing maturity
for someone so young - clearly a star of the future. Duke Special, of
course, is very much a star of the present, and unsurprisingly
garnered the biggest cheers from the audience for his contributions.
But the highlight section for me was the two second performances from
Cathy Burton and Gordon Gano respectively, who each chose a worship
song. Cathy's song was one she'd written herself for use in her own
church when leading worship shortly after the death of a friend's
nine-day old baby, while Gordon led us all in a traditional
call-and-response American spiritual based around the theme of the
Messiah making us happy - complete with laughing policeman style "ha
ha ha ha ha" refrain. The two songs were so different in both theme
and style that the juxtaposition could have been awkward, and yet in
reality it wasn't at all - rather, it was a celebration of the
diversity of worship music. Plus, of course, you don't often get to
experience a scratch worship band with Marytn Joseph on guitar, Duke
Special on keyboards and Gordon Gano and Cathy Burton on vocals!
Mark Goodge
THE SUSPECTORS - Underground - 12:40pm
With
their selection of self-penned songs and covers, including a rocked
out version of "House Of The Rising Sun", these dynamic Cheltenham
youngsters bore a slight resemblance to Muse with their squealing
guitar lines. Making waves last year after touring in the Lake Garda
area of Italy lead singer Fabio Thomas' rugged voice was perfectly
suited to soar over the crunching rhythms. He successfully engaged the
crowd with his quick wit in between songs, and most clapped, some even
sang, along with him.
Andrew Townend
LIFECOLOUR - Underground - 1:20pm
Cross Rhythms
Radio listeners will already be familiar with this teenage band from
Stoke-on-Trent as a number of their melodic indie rock tunes have been
selected for airplay over the past couple of years. This was the
band's first visit to Greenbelt and after a slightly nervous start the
four-piece soon settled into a groove and second number "Hello Good
Morning" rewarded the surprisingly busy Underground venue with some
pounding Switchfoot-esque rock. The great songs kept on coming:
"Failure & Calamity Always Meet A Remedy", "Above The Clouds" and
"Time To Be Free" all displayed Sam Frawley's passionate vocal
delivery supported by some fine musicianship from his young bandmates.
Lifecolour expertly blend classic pop songwriting with a rock edge and
meaningful lyrics and it's not hard to imagine them playing the
Mainstage in years to come.
Peter Timmis
CHIP KENDALL BAND - Underground - 2:00pm
The
baying crowd received the Chip Kendall Band with huge enthusiasm and
their Scripture-inspired rap songs offered hope to a generation of
young people who may have lost their way. "Let's hear it for grace,"
shouted Chip triumphantly and the crowd responded rapturously. Mr
Kendall's new aggregation showed much of the bombastic flair that made
thebandwithnoname such crowd pleasers and in Roo Walker have one of
the best guitarists in the land. The performance culminated with a
reunion of sorts, as the passionate evangelist was joined by old
bandmate, thebandwithnoname's Straff, as they played fans' favourite
"Amazing Grace". Hard to put a stylistic label on the Chip Kendall
Band. All I can say is, if you think of a Christian version of Limp
Bizkit you can't be too far wrong. The great crowd atmosphere made it
a real hoot while the new songs from the 'K Is For Kendall' went down
well.
Andrew Townend
LOBELIA - Performance Café - 2:30pm
Solo bass anoraks (of whom, to paraphrase Paul, I am chief) were
disappointed that there was no Steve Lawson set scheduled for
Greenbelt this year. Happily the best thing ever to happen to Steve
was about to play a set, together with hubby and some of hubby's
gadgets. Unfortunately for Steve the technology gremlins were biting
hard and he and Lobelia were beset with sound problems, most notably a
subterranean chasm of reverb that caused more than a little gnashing
of teeth from our normally placid friend. With two stunning new albums
to plug, a few sound issues weren't about to dissuade Lobelia, so
while Steve pottered about trying to fix stuff, she opened the set
with the title track from her covers album 'Beautifully Undone',
originally recorded by Canadian/Icelandic singer/songwriter Lindy.
Lobelia possesses a captivating voice and a wonderfully gentle guitar
technique, a style which paints a different picture of some of the
songs she has chosen for the album. Who, for instance, would have
expected to hear an acoustic arrangement of Dead Or Alive's '80s
classic "You Spin Me Round", but there it was and it worked
surprisingly well. Steve joined in the set for the duo's arrangement
of Pat Benatar's "Love Is A Battlefield", an eclectic version in which
Steve took one of his effect-laden solos featuring distorted bass and
reverse loops. He had a lot of fun with that one causing Mrs. L to
remark on the truth of the song title. Despite the technical issues
this was a really entertaining set and the crowd lapped it up.
Andy Long
FALLEN TIDE - Underground - 2.40pm
Fallen
Tide are Greenbelt first-timers, winners of the Bath YFC battle of the
bands, their prize being this very gig. On a damp Saturday afternoon,
inside was a good place to be and steam visibly rose from the
enthusiastic crowd. The band confidently ride this wave of affection
and bashed out an upbeat set full of songs that pleased the crowd some
of whom clearly know their stuff already. Frontman Zach Hayes clearly
has an ear for a vocal hook and the lads harmonized well which added
depth to the sound. Hayes dealt well with a broken string in the
middle of "Pop!" - a swift change of guitars and he's barely away from
the mic, recovering quickly and back in the zone without breaking the
flow. Musically, Fallen Tide stick to pretty standard acoustic pop
rock fare, which occasionally rose above the ordinary when bassist
Charlie Millard got a chance to shine. His lines are, imaginative and
energetic. But even Millard's dexterity could'nt stop "Missing You"
from sounding soppy nonsense - no song should start "I'm sitting here,
all alone" but 'Feel The Same' brought me back onboard. Official fan
favourite (according to a Facebook vote) "Left Behind" was the
highlight of the set - again, the bass leads the way and the rhythm
section comes to life. There's some indication that taking the music
in a slightly funkier direction could prove the key to a more
distinctive sound. Yes, there's a touch of Mumford And Sons at times,
particularly in Hayes' faux-folk vocals but influences also stem from
further back as a cover of the Stereophonics' "Have A Nice Day"
testified.
Ewan Jones
JOE ROSE - Mainstage - 4:50pm
Wow. I wasn't
expecting this! Joe Rose - joined by sister, Esther and brother, Jack
came onstage with the poise and look of a hero in a Victorian gothic
romance and proceeded to belt out a dramatic, engaging, romantic and
tragic set of songs that managed to channel the Sisters Of Mercy via
Enya, or, when Esther sang, perhaps a goth tribute to Kate Bush. I'm
not making myself clear - all of this preamble is to say that Joe's
set was one of the unexpected highlights of the GB'11 weekend. The
definitely won't have been a set that began more dramatically with
lush keys, Rose's soaring violin looped and feeding back, building to
create an swathe of sound. Armed with a floor tom and playing his
guitar one-handed the set continued with bold, driving bass riffs, a
riveting performance across the board and a huge sound. The beautiful
"Till I'm Dust" left me reeling with its intensity and it was followed
by a brief foray into major key territory for "Likely Lads". The set
ended in a characteristically emotive fashion, huge reverb on the
drums, a tolling bell and a mournful violin melody floating above - it
made me want to go and find a moor to roam just as the sun came
out.
Ewan Jones
LISTENER - Mainstage - 5:50pm
Listener were
described in the Greenbelt programme as combining "poetry and stomping
rhythms to make an authentic hollering noise to wake all the American
South". Expecting something along the lines of folk Americana, and
arriving slightly late at mainstage, I initially thought I'd got my
times wrong and turned up at a heavy metal act instead. But no, this
was the duo I'd intended to see. Dubbed "talk music", Listener's
unique style consists of screeching guitars underlying a spoken and
shouted lyric. And when I say "unique", I really do mean unique - I
have honestly never heard anything like it before in my life. Elements
of hip-hop, rap, country, folk and grunge metal all find their way in
there. The songs - if you can call them that, maybe monologues is a
better description - cover an equally wide range of topics, from
glaciers to relationships. The small, but enthusiastic, crowd were a
testament to the Marmite qualities of Listener - this is not a band
that you can sit on the fence with. But, once I'd got my head around
what I was hearing, I found myself increasingly drawn in. Two of the
standout tracks for me were a cover of Pedro The Lion's "Priests and
Paramedics" and a self-penned reflection on life based around the
story of a poverty-stricken congregation from the Deep South who had
built a church out of wood from shipwrecks. "We're all made out of
shipwrecks", mused the speaker as the guitars wailed in the
background.
Mark Goodge
JUDAH AND SECRET - Underground - 6:45pm
"There aren't many people here but we're going to rock it like
there's thousands!" shouted Judah as the London-based hip-hop duo took
to the stage of an almost deserted Underground - in fact the venue's
staff initially outnumbered audience members! Producer Secret and MC
Judah are, of course, ex-members of pioneering Christian hip-hop
aggregation GreenJade and they have lost none of the sharp rhymes and
big beats that made that group so great. The show was a little rough
around the edges with some backing track issues but Judah And Secret
kept the small crowd on their side with witty between song banter and
even handed out CDs to the audience members who shouted the loudest.
As the crowd grew towards the end of the set the duo's performance
became more and more energetic and reached a climax with the utterly
brilliant Radio 1Xtra playlisted "Do What You Do". First rate hip-hop
from an amazingly talented duo.
Peter Timmis
GORDON GANO & THE RYAN BROTHERS - Mainstage -
7:00pm
I approached this gig by the veteran American
with mixed feelings. On the plus side Gano's folk/punk band of the
1980s, the Violent Femmes, recorded a classic, "Jesus Walking On The
Water" (recently featured in CR's Spirit Of Rock And Soul series). On
the minus side the only time I'd seen Gano live he was leading the
short-lived Mercy Seat who played Greenbelt back in the mid '80s where
micro-minnied singers sang covers of old black gospel songs to bemused
Greenbelt punters. But I needn't have worried. Despite never
approaching the wild excitement of the Femmes, Gano and the Ryan
Brothers produced a good set of rollicking Americana. When he slowed
the pace for one piano-dominated the effect was less good with Gano's
creaking voice - always an acquired taste - jarring despite the
passion it engendered. But when Gordon and the Brothers kept it upbeat
and rocking with good ol' Southern States rhythms the effect was
engaging even if the small-but-growing crowd waiting for Duke Special
in the windy sunshine didn't seem too interested one way or another.
But I enjoyed Gano's gothic tales of faith and the sight of Gano with
a fiddle in hand exhorting the crowd in his gnarled Southern drawl to
read their Bibles was hard to resist.
Tony Cummings
THE AUSTIN FRANCIS CONNECTION - Underground -
7:45pm
This quirky and unique hip-hop aggregation from
Gloucestershire are now such firm festival favourites that they
received whoops and cheers from the eager Underground crowd even as
they set up their equipment in the packed venue. But bad news was just
around the corner; after an extended appearance with Get Cape. Wear
Cape. Fly on the Mainstage the previous night, AFC's beatboxer Hobbit
had been diagnosed with a serious case of tonsillitis and would have
to miss the show. With one third of their crew missing, bespectacled
frontman Edi Johnston and guitarist Mark Finney called on a little
help from friends, audience members and several mugs of hot tea to put
on a humourous and charming performance. Drums on the opening number
"Jobcentre" were provided by a pal of the group, John, and former
thebandwithnoname MC Ad-Apt contributed some beatboxing to the
hilarious "Ginger Pride". Hobbit's absence provided AFC with the
perfect opportunity to play the rarely performed "Can You See The
Stars?" which displayed their more delicate side. Despite clearly
missing Hobbit, The Austin Francis Connection still put on a great
show.
Peter Timmis
Andrew Townend is being WAY too soft on Duke Special about his Mainstage set and inparticular the Duke's closing remarks. DS helpfully told us to 'f*** denominations', without setting any personal context (NI?), or giving any further explanation or insight in to his well constructed argument - just throwing that out was a sour way to end the set and a 'shock' tactic to try and appear outspoken and 'other' in front of the very audience that has helped get him where he is.
Artistically, tacking his intellectually devoid contribution on to the end of 'Love Will Tear Us Apart' added further confusion as it made NO sense in the context of the song - is he saying Jesus' love causes people to tear apart, or our love for Jesus is earnest to the point where we tear him apart? Stupid, stupid, stupid, and I don't buy Townend's generous analysis either.
Greenbelt and its regular performers have a responsibility - what they say and do matters. Artistic expression does not trump integrity. Perhaps GB should give DS a year off.
By complete chance I was at the first greenbelt gig (I think) Duke Special ever did - 50 people in the old performance cafe - Duke with a piano and a gramophone, Chip with his percussion stick, and it was a revelation - as of GB11 the make-up's running, the charm has worn off and the novelty presentation ceases to be a draw. Shame, because there's some good songs kicking around in there.
Final thought - this is not a moral judgement (if you want to say f***, say f***), it's just an expression of frustration/disappointment - I'm almost reluctant to write it because I don't want Duke fans to pounce to his defence and make a martyr of a man who's quite capable of speaking for himself - certainly more articulately than he did in August.