Our annual music review of the GREENBELT festival held at Cheltenham Racecourse.
Continued from page 4
ELLIE WILLIAMS - Performance Café - 3:15pm
Female singer/songwriters line the pathways of the music scene like
lamp-posts line roads; you never walk too far before you find one. So
when you come across one who shines brighter than most, it's time to
stand in her light and bask. That's what I did when Ellie Williams
played solo with her piano. I pooh-poohed the compère when he
reported that Ellie has been described as "Kate Bush meets Coldplay".
I similarly took little notice when he said that she didn't "so much
tug at your heartstrings as reach inside and shake them loose". 20
minutes later, however, I was wiping my moist eyes. She had hit my
soft spot all too easily and she DOES have the phrasing of Kate Bush's
gentler moments, as she proved when her account of "A Woman's Work"
stood up proudly to Bush's own version. Ellie's set began with
"Unseen", the title track to her current fan-funded album, and another
strong composition, "Firefly". After a few heart-rending songs she
lightened the mood with the grounded "You & Me". The set hit its
peak with a superb tribute to her baby nephew, "Finn's Song". The
chorus is inspiring on its own: "Laugh with all your lungs until it
hurts some/Stand with all your strength, though it might take
some/Believe in all your dreams and you might make some/Love with all
your heart and it may break some." Her vocals LIVED the song. As a
guitarist might press a pedal to let the fuzz or reverb kick in, she
pressed a mental button and her oh-so-expressive voice could either
click straight into soaring mode or soothe right down. It was a real
disappointment that I had to leave two songs from the end, but not
before deciding that her CD was an essential for the checking out
list.
Derek Walker
STEREO INFLUENCE - Underground - 4:15pm
The
Greenbelt programme described this young Cheltenham-based three-piece
as "rough and ready garage rock" but, as I discovered, a more accurate
description would be "indie by numbers". The catchy "Where Is Love"
featured a strong guitar riff but more effort in the arrangement and
lyrics is required and "What She Said" was too close to the sound of
the Arctic Monkeys for comfort. A major flaw was that the band
delivered their songs with virtually no personality and when they did
make contact with the audience one wished they hadn't bothered, eg "We
couldn't think of a name for this song so we called it 'Fast One'."
What imagination! And despite a punchy drum shuffle, it wasn't
actually very fast. After 20 minutes word came from stage side that
time was up and the band shrugged their shoulders and slouched off.
Peter Timmis
ARUN GHOSH - Big Top - 4:30pm
Greenbelt is
always a festival to try and be inclusive of different cultures of art
and here was a great example of their mindset. Why else would Arun
Ghosh, an Indo jazz musician who incorporates the rhythms and scales
from India, with inspiration from Bengali folk music, be at a
predominately Christian festival? Now based in London, although
originally from Manchester, Arun himself professes that at age 13 his
dad wouldn't let him come to Greenbelt, so some 20 years later he was
really happy to be performing at the festival! And it showed. This was
a truly inspirational performance with Arun and his clarinet. The
pieces (all written by Arun and his band) were the perfect combination
of traditional, modern and a hint of fusion jazz interlaced with
Bengali rhythms which were expertly played with the assistance of
Liran Donin on double bass, Kishen Khan on keys, Pat Illingworth on
drums and Nilesh Gulhane on tabla. The whole band had a great full
sound and the often syncopated rhythms were truly infectious. The
assembled throng lapped it up and Arun and the band quite rightly
received a standing ovation at the end of the gig. Here's hoping that
Greenbelt invite him back and put him up on Mainstage as he would
certainly deliver.
Simon Akehurst
THE VIOLET BURNING - Mainstage - 5:25pm
"We're The Violet Burning and we're from somewhere over the sea,"
announced Michael J Pritzl, frontman of the pioneering alt rockers
from California. "It's good to be here, it's been a few years."
Considering that Cross Rhythms first enthused about this extraordinary
ensemble after Greenbelt 1992 and after all these years Pritzl, with
younger musos in tow, is still flying The Violet Burning flag one
might have expected a rather subdued set. Instead the growing crowd
enjoying the glorious bank holiday sunshine were treated to a
spectacular, roaring wall of sound that no doubt reached all corners
of the Cheltenham site. Michael conveys passion like few other singers
and with the veteran writhing on the floor with his guitar howling
like a banshee during a jaw-dropping rendition of 1996's "Low" it's
clear that the frontman still understands the power of rock 'n' roll
theatrics. "I love the Bible. It's full of stories about people like
you and me and God wants to step into your story," he told the throng
before the band performed a blistering version of "Underwater" which
grew majestically with incredibly powerful drumming from Lenny Beh.
The interplay between the guitars of Pritzl and Chris Buelow was a
sonic delight with plenty of "how are they making that sound?"
moments. As the band closed with "Gorgeous" one fan enthused that The
Violet Burning were the "band of the weekend". He could well be
right.
Peter Timmis
FOY VANCE - Mainstage - 6:30pm
I was
surprised, and delighted, when Foy made an unbilled Mainstage
appearance thanks to the non-arrival of "Gil Scott Lost" (Foy's
twice-repeated quip). Foy had, apparently, had trouble with his loop
machine during his Centaur gig so this time it was the loops that
dominated his set. And certainly, Foy's ability to quickly construct
lolloping, funky grooves of guitar, rhythm and several vocal parts was
a wonder to behold while his vocals, a gutsy rasp of pent up passion,
would put most blue-eyed soul men to shame. What was lacking in his
set were one or two of his brilliant ballad compositions (I'm sure his
classic "Gabriel & The Vagabond" would have gripped the audience
if he'd cared to sing it). But it was looped grooves that dominated
and they were never less than impressive even when he admitted after
one song to singing a part out-of-tune. The real surprise was the
closer when he took the old Michael Jackson warhorse "Billie Jean",
slowed it down and demonstrated what a great song it is at any tempo.
Overall, a clever performance from the Celtic soul man though I
probably wasn't alone in wishing there'd been a bit less technology
and a bit more man-and-guitar in Foy's set.
Tony
Cummings
JARS OF CLAY - Mainstage - 7:50pm
The
first time I saw Jars Of Clay was in a small club shortly before 'Jars
Of Clay' was released. They had some great songs ("Flood", "Liquid",
"Like A Child") but little or no stage presence. The second time I saw
the band was in 2008 when they topped the bill at Stoke-on-Trent's
Adoration Fest and the transformation was truly remarkable. With a
literally dazzling lightshow, remarkable technique which fused
harmonies, memorable keyboard lines and intricate guitar interplay
plus in Dan Haseltine a frontman you couldn't take your eyes off, they
were unquestionably world class. At GB '10, having been bumped up the
Mainstage bill thanks to Gil Scott Heron's no-show, I can report that,
if anything, Jars Of Clay were even better than their Stoke
appearance. Those rock purists who had mistakenly written off the Jars
as a band lacking true rock'n'roll bite must have been astonished by
the sheer energising dynamics of their go-for-the-jugular guitar sound
while the inventiveness of their light show brought visual vibrancy to
gems old - "Flood", given a completely invigorating arrangement, and
"Love Song For A Saviour" - and new - "Work" and "Dead Man (Carry
Me)". It is of course the songwriting craft and sheer memorability of
the Jars' best material which makes them stand out from the crowd and
long before their final crescendo the large Greenbelt throng were
baying their appreciation. All in all, a triumphant return to
Greenbelt for the CCM hitmakers.
Tony Cummings
THE KING BLUES - Mainstage - 9:30pm
Upon hearing that Gil Scott-Heron had pulled out of his headlining
slot I was excited to hear that The King Blues were taking his place.
Having just appeared on the Mainstage at Leeds/Reading Festival it was
going to be interesting to see how they went down with the Greenbelt
crowd. The band were greeted with rapturous applause and wasted no
time getting the party going with their mix of reggae, folk, ska and
punk. They played a good range of material from both studio albums
alongside newer material and from where I was standing I couldn't see
a person left standing still. From the fists in the air chanting
anthem "My Boulder" to the gritty love song "Underneath The Lamppost
Light" everyone was enraptured by the band's sterling performance. The
new songs from their forthcoming album "Holiday" and "Headbutt" look
set to being firm live favourites, with the band getting the crowd to
join in on the choruses. Between a number of their songs the band
paused to voice their concerns of fascism within Britain but also
adding that "there are more of us than them" and that "the streets are
ours". The band, known for their strong political statements, also
praised Greenbelt for its support of social justice campaigns and
pursuit of equality. A few solo songs from Johnny 'Itch' Fox and his
ukulele added an intimacy that proved that The King Blues are able to
captivate an audience even without a full band. That certainly goes
someway to proving just why Kerrang awarded them Best Live Band this
year. A small acoustic drive went down a treat with "I Got Love" and
set closer "Save The World, Get The Girl". The panic on the security
staff's faces was all too apparent when the band urged as many "people
on shoulders" as possible; many were thwarted in their attempts but
plenty others managed. It may have gone against health and safety but
it was a great sight to bring a great festival to an end.
Gavin Owen
I agree it would be good to see more Christian music on mainstage. The social justice theme is great but there might be a danger of losing the Christian distinctiveness of Greenbelt. And with the discussions and talks of course you need to be discerning about what you take in as there is quite a range of ideas around but I always question things anyway. I think that is a healthy approach. Nevertheless I find that there is so much choice in the festival as a whole that there is still a lot to keep my interest both musically and spiritually. Every year I go I am impressed by the worship and greatly encouraged to go deeper in God.