In what is now an annual service to Greenbelt goers and Christian music buffs generally, from 22nd to 25th August Cross Rhythms had a team of reviewers at Cheltenham Racecourse to report on Greenbelt '08. Here is the final version of their reviews.
Continued from page 4
BRIAN HOUSTON - Performance Café -
1.30pm
Given an extended slot due to Fightstar getting
stuck in traffic and not making it to the site in time, Belfast
singer/songwriter Brian Houston took full advantage with a high-energy
performance that mixed music with the touch of a comedian - the crowd
alternately roaring with laughter and singing along with the songs
(including the radio hits "Oranges" and "End Of The Beginning") drawn
from all of Brian's past few albums as well as some older classics.
It's difficult, in the space of a one-paragraph review, to convey the
highlights of the gig since so much of it lay in the banter and
interplay between performer and audience, so you'll just have to take
my word for it that this was very, very good indeed.
Mark
Goodge
NEW LIFE MUSIC SHOWCASE - YMCA Fresh Talent Stage -
2.00pm
I arrived at the Fresh Talent Stage as Electric
Nightmares were nearing the end of their set. For one of the younger
bands on the New Life Music showcase they have a great sound, blending
the harmonies amongst their three singers. They sound like a band
growing with confidence, mixing their own material with popular
covers. Melodic pop-rock band Gleam Of Dawn were next up with their
riff-laden sound. Their most impressive song was "Broken Down" which
was funnily enough a stripped down affair with a very nice
arrangement. Frontman Maic Clark hasn't got the strongest voice for
the rock material but the energy is apparent and this can only
develop. They need to define their sound more as they continue to make
passionate music inspiring others to follow Christ. Good Question
appeared onstage as the final act of the showcase, with a smart and
stylish appearance defying the fact that they'd worn the same now
unwashed and slightly muddy clothes at two other gigs. They were ready
for a good time despite the palpable tiredness of the festival-goers,
and gradually won the audience with a rock version of Beyonce's "Crazy
In Love". The drummer is an absolute livewire, seemingly using every
possible bone and muscle to rock out while singing along in the
seemingly insignificant absence of a microphone. Along with their
anthemic new single "Be A Star", it made Good Question a joy to watch,
and proved the showcase of bands from North-East organisation New Life
Music to be a worthy addition to the ever-expanding Greenbelt
programme.
Tom Whitman
MARTIN JOSEPH - Centaur - 2.15pm
The
sense of anticipation and excitement were palpable as I joined the
back of a monster queue for Joseph's Greenbelt set for this year.
Struggling to find a space to sit myself in the packed out Centaur,
Joseph was already two songs into his set by the time the stewards had
crammed us in, and there were still at least 200 people behind us.
Happily, Joseph didn't disappoint. It was a faultless example of how
one boyo armed with a guitar, a harmonica and a bottle of water can
hold 3000 people in the palm of his hand. Martin is more on top of his
game than ever - his confidence, storytelling and sense of humour
shone through and he interacted with his audience in a way that
carried all the intimacy of a gig in the Underground or Performance
Cafe - I forgot for a moment that I was in the balcony of Greenbelt's
second largest venue. The set was peppered with new material as well
as favourites from the back-catalogue. "Can't Breathe", well suited to
the acoustic treatment, captivated the audience; from gentle verse to
intense conclusion it's a masterclass in honest songwriting. "Turn Me
Tender", also from the 'Deep Blue' album, was the most delicate of
touches after his classic, emotion filled cover of Joan Osbourne's
"What If God Was One Of Us?" (he recently shared a bill with Osbourne
at a Canadian musical festival, but refrained from showing her how to
play her own song). The set ended with the title track from new album
'Vegas' - it's a song that carries a great story behind it, plenty of
energy and fun, Elvis homages, and a singalong chorus which is sure to
be an audience favourite in future shows. Martin also figures that
he's the second Welshman ever, after Tom Jones, to play a Vegas casino
- true or not, it's a great claim that raised a laugh and some
patriotic cries from the Welsh contingent. Martin spoke of "coming
home" to Greenbelt after a busy summer schedule and that pleasure was
evident in his heartfelt performance. With exquisite guitar playing
and lyrics that are as deep and intelligent, scathing and political as
anything Bob Dylan ever wrote, Wales' favourite poet gave his audience
the show they hoped for.
Ewan Jones
A FAILED PERFECTION - Underground - Monday 2.35pm
One of my highlights from last year's Greenbelt had to be one of
Redemption Awaits' last ever shows before disbanding. From the ashes
of that fine technical melodic hardcore act came A Failed Perfection
with half of this band having played in Redemption Awaits. More of the
melodic and less of the hardcore and you can actually start to see a
few loose comparisons. They'll hate me for saying this but these guys
perhaps better fit into the emo mould, whilst still maintaining a
reasonable degree of individual identity and ingenuity. A few months
back I got hold of their début EP, which was a fairly rough and ready
live recording of their early material. Most of those songs have
survived, albeit with a tweak here and there, bolstered by some strong
newer material. The beauty of this type of music is that it really
does nicely fit the emotive and heartfelt lyrics which seep out of
each song. They didn't perhaps boast the finest melodic vocals but a
decent scream here or there allowed a nice balance of quiet and loud.
A Failed Perfection are clearly a band still on the learning curve
before their first full release but already they've established their
own sound. Things look good for the future.
Greg Sammons
BACK POCKET PROPHET - Underground - 3.20pm
Last
year I started my review of this band with this blatantly obvious
sentence, "This is obviously a band who love their metal" and ended it
by saying, "This is a band that feels like it's in its infancy but
could well mature into a very savage and powerful beast." Firstly, I
must stop using the phrase "this is a band" quite so often, of course
they're a band, but secondly the first quote remains completely valid
and the second quote/prophecy is really starting to take shape. A
line-up change since last year sees the guitarist and bassist share
vocal duties after their lead singer left late last year (don't worry,
it was all amicable). So less of the cookie-monster vocals and more of
your typical thrash metal lead vocals teamed with grunting backing
vocals. The more thrashy vocals have been met with a more thrashy
sound overall, clearly doing what they love to do most. Their new
material is their strongest yet, always a good indication that things
are going in the right direction. In an interview I asked them who
they'd most like to gig with, bands like Iron Maiden, Metallica and
Megadeth were highest on the wish list. It's fairly clear that these
guys have been born 20 years too late! Without doubt the highlight of
this full on metal assault was their introduction of the conga-mosh
and then Vic joining us in the crowd to join in with the fun. An
entertaining set for metal fans allowing themselves an indulgence into
the old school sound.
Greg Sammons
ESTHER ALEXANDER - Performance Café -
4.00pm
Esther Alexander has the kind of voice and style
of songs that were seemingly made for this type of intimate yet
relaxed setting. Ably accompanied by Dave Clifton on guitar, Esther
treated us to a selection of songs from her latest album, 'Last Of The
Hopeless Romantics', as well as dipping into her back catalogue of
soul-tinged R&B to provide the appreciative audience with a
relaxing afternoon's listening.
Mark Goodge
DESERT SUN - Underground - 4.05pm
The Meltdown
stage seems to be more varied this year with hardcore, punk, thrash
and now a classic old school metal band similar to Alice in Chains
mixed with Deep Purple. Desert Sun are from Birmingham and have been
together for nearly two years, of which 18 months were spent
rehearsing before playing any gigs. They are already attracting the
interest of a couple of record labels. This isn't as surprising as it
may seem. Who would have predicted that Def Leppard would do a
sell-out tour! Desert Sun has come along just at the right time to
fill a gap in the hard music scene. Kev (drums) and Andy Greaves
(bass) cut their teeth in Gen, who released one awesome album 'Rite Of
Refusal' before disappearing. They are joined by Joff Williams (rhythm
guitar) and Steve Cumberland (lead guitar and vocals) to make a groove
based band firing on all four cylinders. "Souperman" starts off with a
riff before the rest of the band kicks in with driving mid-paced hard
rock. It's great to hear songs that give plenty of space to hear the
ample guitar licks in "Final Game". They finish off with "Whitesnake"
which I can almost imagine speeding along to, in an open topped car
with wind blowing in my hair.
Peter Willoughby
KASHEE OPEIAH - Underground - 4.50pm
It's rather
sad that for a good number of the crowd watching a fine display of
German progressive hardcore, they're most likely to remember what
happened at the end of the band's set. Prior to a rather strong-handed
eviction of a hardcore kid wanting to express himself by dancing as a
hardcore kid might, the band brought a glorious conclusion to this
year's input from Meltdown Ministries. They were hard and heavy, as
all good hardcore should be, but with lovely delicate and progressive
touches showing just how high their musicianship was. To their
detriment I don't think I'd necessarily recognise a single song of
theirs if I heard it again but I doubt that is something that will
worry them greatly. With a sound akin to the softer side of the
noisecore movement, you'd assume that bands like Norma Jean, Zao and
Glassjaw would pay a fairly heavy influence. But these guys take the
music further on to create large musical soundscapes. Whilst they may
not be any technically better than the noisecore big boys, they do
seem more willing to bring more melody and diversity to the pace and
direction of their sound. I wouldn't say they took my breath away in
terms of the outcome of their experimentation but I was still
impressed that they at least tried. Some nice moments mixed with some
crushing beatdowns, one of the better bands to grace the Underground
stage this year.
Greg Sammons
MXPX - Mainstage - 8:10pm
For a band
that have been around for over 15 years, it's somewhat surprising that
this was the first appearance at Greenbelt (as one stop on a UK tour
to promote the latest album, 'Secret Weapon') for the boys from
Bremerton. No surprise then, that when lead singer Mike Herrera asked
how many in the crowd had seen them live before, only a handful
responded in the affirmative. But that didn't seem to be a problem, as
the band have a strong UK following - a sizable proportion of the
audience were familiar enough with the pop-punk songs to take the
opportunity offered by their first-time MxPx gig to sing along
heartily to a selection of tracks from 'Secret Weapon', as well as
classics from previous releases such as the radio hit "Heard That
Sound" and the set's closer, the evergreen "Punk Rawk Show". And, I
have to confess, it was nice to have a band on Mainstage at Greenbelt
who were there just to have fun, and give the audience a good time,
rather than using the stage as a platform to preach religion and/or
politics. Not that there's anything wrong with religion and politics,
but for the closing night of the weekend most of the crowd just wanted
to let their hair down and Herrera matched the mood with a
proclamation that "a festival is all about enjoying yourself". Amen to
that, brother.
Mark Goodge
FIGHTSTAR - Mainstage - 9.35pm
When
Charlie Simpson announced that he was going to leave Busted as he
wanted to be in a "real" metal band, we were all skeptical. Since then
Fightstar have released 'Grand Unification', 'One Day Son, This Will
All Be Yours' and a covers album 'Alternate Endings' of post-hardcore,
emo-rock often compared to Biffy Cyclo. Having worked so hard on their
new career, I suppose that Fightstar need to keep their credibility in
the metal scene. So it wasn't too much of a surprise when the drummer
did the double handed "horns" gesture when he came onstage. But I can
envisage some parents writing in to Greenbelt to complain that this
wasn't suitable or acceptable for a Christian festival. The crowd were
already hyped up from MxPx, but the stewards were not allowing crowd
surfing and also frowned upon anyone forming a mosh pit. They stormed
through "Palahniuks Laughter", "99", "Grand Unification Part 1", "We
Apologise For Nothing", "I Am The Message", "Amaze Us" and "Build An
Army". Then they subjected us to an acoustic version of The Cure's
"Inbetween Days". Unfortunately, Charlie does not have the vocal range
to carry this off convincingly. After another acoustic song,
"Amethyst", they launched off again at what they do best with some of
their more extreme material "Tannhauser Gate", "Waste A Moment",
"Paint Your Target" and "Deathcar". They left the stage to return with
"Mono" as the encore. Personally, I enjoyed their performance, though
I suspect that Fightstar's set was simply too heavy for many in the
crowd.
Peter Willoughby
I particularly enjoyed Andensum - Underground - 11.20am. Its a shame they didn't get reviewed. What a top band.
Considering such an early hour here was an exciting energy filled solid performance which was like a raucous alarm going off in a midsummers dream to all the bewildered and flagging 'belters.
I'm not sure everyone recognises Epic that early in the morning but a few ears were pinned back during this onslaught of riffs and melodies that makes this band listenable watchable and most definitely different. Definitely deserve a return slot