In what is now an annual service to Greenbelt goers and Christian music buffs generally, from 22nd to 25th August Cross Rhythms had a team of reviewers at Cheltenham Racecourse to report on Greenbelt '08. Here is the final version of their reviews.
Continued from page 1
SOMETHING FOR SOPHIE - YMCA Fresh Talent Stage -
2:30pm
Something For Sophie have the potential to become
a pop-rock phenomenon across the UK. Notching up a fair few plays on
their myspace caught the attention of the organisers of the YMCA Fresh
Talent Stage at Greenbelt. Suffice to say they were duly booked. With
killer hooks, brilliant melodies and an explosive live performance
they had the tent truly swelling at the seams. The back of the tent
was about the only place to congregate for latecomers drawn to the
impassioned delivery of songs like "Day Of Your Life" and "Chasing
Venezuela", which will see them pick up fans as quickly as the
Greenbelt volunteers can pick up litter from the empty site. Something
For Sophie are a band to watch indeed and accolades to the Fresh
Talent organisers for spotting them.
Tom Whitman
THE STEELS - Underground - 3.30pm
After the
delay following a false fire alarm interrupting
Deathisnotwelcomehere's set, The Steels bring a rather light sounding
start to the Meltdown Sessions - usually renowned for bringing us the
heaviest stuff at the festival. But these are a tight trio of pop
rockers who know how to put a smile on your face and a bounce in your
step. I've known about these guys for a couple of years but this is
the first time I've caught them live. I wasn't bowled over with them
but they did enough to keep my interest. Considering they went full
time this summer I fear they'll need to do a little bit more to keep
crowds interested for longer periods of time and get the illustrious
invite back to a venue played before. Plus whilst the music was fun
and entertaining, the patois of the guys was far from captivating -
but then I guess it's not their role to compete with the likes of
[dweeb], My Spoon and Austin Francis Connection, all who know how to
do more than just create good music. The Steels' second album, which
came out early on this year, was a great improvement on their debut
and it's good to hear most of their set given over to the newer stuff.
If you like the Busted and McFly mould of fun and tuneful pop rock,
you should investigate The Steels.
Greg Sammons
IAIN ARCHER & FRIENDS - Centaur -
3:30pm
Iain Archer chose this opportunity to air songs
from new album 'To The Pine Roots', which was launched at Greenbelt.
With a brand new guitar for which he had forgotten to buy a strap, he
came out on his own and set the mood for his fresh, more understated
direction. Wife Miriam, who had literally just arrived from London,
entered the stage after a couple of numbers, gave Iain a quick hug and
was joined by Gabi Froden to sing angelic backing vocals in the fluent
story of "The Acrobat". The almost cracked fragility of Archer's voice
was complimented by the atmosphere and dynamics driven by the stellar
Phil Wilkinson on brushes and Jon Kensington on double bass. Iain's
parents and in-laws helped make up a choir on "To Mend And Move
Along", making it a truly friends and family affair. The captivating
"Canal Song" from the fantastic previous album 'Magnetic North' was
given a particularly warm reception by the crowd in the wonderful
Centaur. Yet new song "The Everest" was saved for the set closer,
building gradually with some sweet guitar from Archer, whose distinct
picking style was consummate throughout. A stunningly soulful choir
made up of Miriam Archer, Gabi Froden, the Archer and Kaufmann
parents, Julie Lee, Aaron Roach and Foy Vance joined in for the song's
refrain of "Some other day, when my morning comes/I'll be the one
that's waited all night." This was the set highlight of an intimate
gig that warmly involved friends and family, and particularly the
in-laws at whose house amidst the quiet setting of a German black
forest he wrote and recorded many of these tender songs.
Tom
Whitman
KINZLI - Performance Café - 4.00pm
An oriental
girl in a floral dress sings a jazz-style song with a violinist and
bass player helping her out. The lyrics, about the exploited poor, are
sincere but clumsy and only on the scat singing outro does it all meld
together. Kinzli in a South Korean-born,London-based singer and
according to the Greenbelt programme her debut album 'Going Just To Be
Going' is out now on Polkadot Records. By her third song I've decided
I won't go to the G Music Store in search of a copy. Kinzli's songs
strike me as rather dull and full of clumsy phrases that don't scan
too well. So whether she's singing about important topics like the
political turmoil in Burma ("We walk for peace.carry on, carry on,
carry on-on-on") or a song about her boyfriend which, rather
strangely, she sings in Spanish, it fails to grab me. Kinzli's rather
reedy voice and at times plinking, perfunctory accompaniments don't
add up to a great deal either. By the close many in the audience have
drifted away.
Tony Cummings
IGNITED - Underground - 4.15pm
I like these
guys, every time I see them they always try to keep improving and
evolving their sound plus they're a good bunch of lads to get on with
as well. But it was clear to most of the crowd that they'd fallen foul
to the below par abilities of the Underground sound technicians. At
times you could hardly tell they were the melodic hardcore outfit they
claimed to be as their sound was softened far too much, mainly due to
the guitars not getting enough volume. The keyboards, added exactly
one year ago at last year's Greenbelt, continue to improve and be a
more integral part of their sound. It added some nice extra layers -
albeit ones which don't always overlay as best they could. One of the
highlights for me was their penultimate song in the set, a new one
entitled "Flick Of The Switch". It's good to hear their sound and
technical ability improve since shifting from their pop-punk roots to
this more melodic hardcore sound. Another sign of their move away from
being a generic punk band is that next year sees them change their
band name when they release their new album; I'm looking forward to it
already.
Greg Sammons
THE IRRELEVANTS - Underground - 5.00pm
The
Irrelevants are from Accrington and started life as a covers band in
2003. With all the black and white chequered stuff on their new EP
'"dARed Says It's Grand' you would think that they were a ska band.
Well it seems that I've been fooled as they turn out to be a pop-punk
band with spiky hair, pogo power and northern grit. The three piece
let rip through "DOA", "Punk & Anarchy" and "Cheer Up". The latter
song has great lyrics, "Well all I see is emo kids with fringe over
one eye/My Chemical Romance told them it's cool to cry/Skinny jeans
and skinny tops, tattoos that they'll regret ./I wish these people
would cheer up/So cheer up guys, no need to be sad." Then they
bludgeon their way through "Barbie Girl" along with the elephant
mascot that came out and danced during some of the songs. It was
already hot in the Underground, so I don't know how he managed to keep
going without keeling over from heat exhaustion. A few more songs on
and they are riffing through their own composition "She's Got A
Boyfriend". I wasn't expecting to see a punk band on the Meltdown
stage in the Underground, yet they seemed to be well received by the
crowd.
Peter Willoughby
HELEN J HICKS - Performance Café - 5.00pm
Hicks' set brought a jazzy feel to the Performance Cafe - the sun
had stayed out and her laid back tunes made great listening on a warm
August afternoon. Sassy and sweet, Hicks glowed from behind the
keyboard, almost every song introduced with warm humour. She switched
between bold and intimate moments with ease, aided by guitarist Simon
Nelson whose subtle but confident playing brought further swing to the
proceedings. "Barbie With Soul" got the crowd grinning, while "Perfect
On Paper" (which could have come across like the obligatory song that
men have to skip on Alanis Morissette CDs so they don't feel
inadequate) was sharply written and performed with tongue in cheek (No
mean feat. Ed) - throughout the set Hicks' humour and clever
composition shone through. Hicks toured with Larry Norman shortly
after meeting him at Greenbelt when she was 18, and talked of looking
forward to playing "I Wish We'd All Been Ready" in Sunday's tribute to
Norman - sadly, the crowd were not granted an advance listen, but the
10 songs on offer, including two songs that Hicks wrote and released
as charity fundraising singles, made for an enjoyable 40 minutes of
jazz-tinged pop music.
Ewan Jones
THE ROYAL WELCOME - YMCA Fresh Talent Stage -
5.00pm
Ah youth! A lad in a crumpled shirt who looks
like he's studied every move in the MTV Book Of Rock Band Cliches is
crouched over the mic while his fellow band members create a joyfully
jagged rock racket. This bunch of young men from Leicester play punchy
hard rock with a tightness that belies their youth and though they
overdo the rock hero posturing they're good with some complex time
changes even recalling the golden age of thrash. Particularly
impressive is their closer "about the overlap between Heaven and
earth." Certainly The Royal Welcome sound good enough to be hiked up
to Greenbelt's Underground venue next year together with the other two
outstanding bands from the Fresh Talent venue, Something For Sophie
and Toxic Federation. It seems Greenbelt can still unearth exciting
grassroots talent.
Tony Cummings
VOICE OF THE MYSTERONS - Underground - 5.40pm
If
Edgar Allen Poe had ever decided to branch out into songwriting after
finishing The Raven then this is the band he might have written for.
This extraordinary aggregation was formed after Blaster The Rocket
Boy/Man's lead singer Otto NoBot (Daniel Petersen) moved to Scotland
and met Dougle, who wanted to form a credible Christian punk band. The
album they wrote is called 'They Have Pulled Down Deep Heaven On Their
Heads OR Come Hell Or High Voltage: An Electromagnetic Rapture Rock
Shock Apocalypse In Dramatic Dialogue With Damned Abaddon's Lost Lads
And Lasses'. Either it's the long lonely nights in the Highlands or
they must put something in the water up there in Livingstone! Voice Of
The Mysterons have unfeasibly long song titles which tell tales of
monsters and mythical beasts whilst the songs themselves have
complicated lyrics and rarely contain any choruses or singalong parts.
They had the lyrics of three songs written out on long poster rolls
stuck to the speaker stacks, which just emphasised the complexity of
the language used. After playing at Cornerstone and a mini American
tour, Dan has perfected the art of jumping from the stage onto the
crash barriers (and then sometimes into the crowd). Dougle, on guitar,
strikes heroic posses in his kilt. He is an imposing figure at six and
a half feet tall, with sideburns that Wolverine would kill for. They
are joined by Francis on bass and the Daveytron XJ5000 rhythm unit.
The audience were stunned by the sonic onslaught of "Sarx Machines Are
Dying To Become Daughters And Sons (Irene, Irene Evangeline)", "The
Ants Of God Are Queer Fish (And Now Walk Gently Through The Fire)" and
"You Don't Understand My 25-Year Transmogrification Plan (An American
Werewolf In Glasgow)". The sheer amount of words crammed into
two-minute songs is spectacular. And because their songs are short,
the Mysterons do several songs in a row, only coming to a halt to give
Dan a chance to get his breath back. "Something Breathes Beside You In
The Darkness" starts off with a spoken word intro of "In the pitch
past midnight, in the last thick-thatched dark-sight before dawn/The
shore shone and I was humbled by what I stumbled upon." As the crowd
leaves, we are in no doubt that we have been subjected to a truly
original band.
Peter Willoughby
JULIE LEE - Mainstage - 6.00pm
After
highly impressive yet short and sweet spots at both Last Orders and
The Rising, a full band backed up Julie Lee on Mainstage. The
Nashville-based singer/songwriter blended the combined influences of
gospel, bluegrass, folk and Maryland jazz, all with a classic American
voice. Most songs slipped between the genres, though her Mainstage
slot was dedicated more to the swing leanings of her 'Take Me Out To
Hear The Band' release, in what was a welcome lazy early evening slot.
She donned the ukulele for the feel good shuffle groove of "Born To
Pine And Sigh" and charmed the crowd after announcing following song
"A Good Man Is Hard To Find", joking "That's because you're all
taken." The teasing cascading rhythms were propelled by Phil Wilkinson
on drums and Jon Kensington on double bass, who both played more than
proficiently after learning the songs on the day. "Before You Came
Along" was the soulful set highlight featuring twinkling piano from
Nathan Phillips, also of Winston Jazz Machine. Julie Lee's artistic
credibility in this set was affirmed not only by her outstanding voice
and fine song craft but also by her generous attitude towards her band
of musicians, giving credit to their contribution and side projects,
many of which appeared at Greenbelt's other venues. Guitarist Aaron
Roach, a brilliant singer/songwriter in his own rite, deserves
particular mention for accompanying her in beautiful fashion
throughout the weekend, his sticker-laden guitar providing a fine solo
on closing song "Little Evening Star". Julie Lee was undoubtedly one
of the most special and defining artists of Greenbelt 2008.
Tom Whitman
CATHY BURTON - Performance Café - 6.00pm
Obviously, there are a lot of performers peddling their wares at
Greenbelt, so by Saturday evening I'd already found myself suffering a
little singer/songwriter fatigue. However, my faith was restored
wonderfully by Cathy Burton, performing her first gig in nine months
after becoming a mum again last year. From the off, Burton was making
excuses for herself (hardly rehearsed, covered in baby sick, got a
stinking cold) but she needn't have because she's a natural talent
and, as Stu G (he of Delirious?, no less) gallantly pointed out, even
with a cold she sings like an angel. Gerrard was providing
accompaniment on guitar and contributed some masterly guitar licks and
occasional vocal harmonies. Although he refused to whistle for the
crowd (I'm not sure how the on stage banter led to that particular
challenge) he did perform "Kingdom Of Comfort" from Delirious?' latest
release. With its brooding chorus and hints of Paranoid Android, it
added a neat balance to Cathy's mostly upbeat numbers. If you asked
any member of the audience what their favourite moment of the set was,
they may just say "Stu G's note perfect rendition of the Postman Pat
theme song in its entirety" - and that would give you an indication of
how free the set was. Cathy sang "Hollow" with breathtaking poignancy
and I realised that it still held the same power over me as it did
when I first heard Cathy perform the song with ex-band Blueberry in my
church hall way too many years ago. Her charming onstage personality
combined with an honest approach to her faith and some deft
songwriting are the reasons that, year after year Cathy is a Greenbelt
favourite.
Ewan Jones
TASTE OF CODA - YMCA Fresh Talent Stage - 6.00pm
Taste Of Coda are a three piece from Hertfordshire with plenty of
strengths but one glaring weakness. Their plusses are a commendable
versatility so that the band is able to punch out power pop, neo
reggae and even a bit of funk while bass and drums are tight and the
guitarist is able to do some interesting things with the loop pedal.
The weakness is that the band don't have an adequate singer so that
despite all his dexterity on guitar, the lad's vocals are painfully
flat. Even the small posse of supporters Taste Of Coda have brought to
whistle and cheer can't hide that fact.
Tony Cummings
HOWE GELB AND GIANT SAND - Mainstage -
7.00pm
I kid you not - 20 minutes into Gelb's set an
eight year old, unknown to me, dressed as Bob The Builder, clasping
his hands to his ears and with a look of sheer distress on his pudgy
face SCREAMED at me, "This is disastrous! This music is terrible! When
will it end?" Eight year olds are fairly honest critics and I realised
that I had to weigh up his comments and figure out whether, in
disagreeing with him, I was being a pretentious muso or not. If his
comments give you some indication of how family unfriendly Gelb's
experimental alt-country was, it does not give you a fair
understanding of the quality of the performance - after all, what does
a kid know when it comes to a band who have been over 25 years in the
business? Gelb began his set from the piano with a beautiful jazz
medley, growling out a haunting verse of "Summertime" with a gravelly,
weary, Arizona desert drawl - think Tom Waits with tonsillitis after a
night on the town. He waxed lyrical about the rain (apparently he had
made it a condition of his performing that Greenbelt must arrange an
adequate downpour - God willingly obliged), before he sang out a love
song, "a postcard... an invitation if you will," to the hot Arizona
desert. The crowd had to work hard as the rain made conditions less
than clement, especially during a set that had kicked off to such a
laid back start. Then we were treated to two versions of the same song
- firstly the "happy" version (which was slow, melancholic and
stunningly beautiful) followed by the "sad" version which was a
bluesy, rock and roll rendition that finally allowed the crowd a
chance to move about a bit. Things got louder and trippier when John
Parish ("all the way from Bristol, England") joined the band on stage.
A cacophony of bizarre and brilliant tunes followed; searing distorted
guitar, hallucinatory country jams and perhaps one too many effects
pedal experiments made for a memorable if not completely accessible
experience that may have suited a more intimate venue for a more
select crowd. Those willing to put in the time, braving the rain to
see a true original were duly satisfied. Eight year old boys, and I
suspect a few others, were not.
Ewan Jones
JOSE GONZALEZ - Mainstage - 8:10pm
Sweden's Jose Gonzalez saw a big crowd gathering at the Mainstage,
those who know his material expectant to hear his captivating live
performance and others intrigued to hear more of an artist they only
recognise from the Sony Brava advert that featured his popular cover
of the song "Heartbeats". With a simple hello and one simple white
spotlight revealing his bearded face, Jose began to weave his musical
magic. As the wind gushed the gathering rain from the top of the stage
onto the eager front section of the crowd, his refreshing atmospheric
songs cast their mysterious spell over the Mainstage. While his songs
can sound similar each one dropped like a star onto the field,
creating and sustaining an atmosphere washed over with delicate
picking and smooth velvety vocals. The meandering duality of the
gentle drawing melodies and classical guitar playing displayed how
close the relationship between his guitar and voice is, showing just
why he has earned comparisons to the ever popular yet deceased Nick
Drake. With the biggest cheer of the night reserved for "Heartbeats",
and people undoubtedly arguing into the night over his cover of
Massive Attack's "Teardrop" and whether it is truer and better than
Newton Faulkner's, he concluded a special set.
Tom
Whitman
I particularly enjoyed Andensum - Underground - 11.20am. Its a shame they didn't get reviewed. What a top band.
Considering such an early hour here was an exciting energy filled solid performance which was like a raucous alarm going off in a midsummers dream to all the bewildered and flagging 'belters.
I'm not sure everyone recognises Epic that early in the morning but a few ears were pinned back during this onslaught of riffs and melodies that makes this band listenable watchable and most definitely different. Definitely deserve a return slot